Buy article online - an online subscription or single-article purchase is required to access this article.
Download citation
Download citation
link to html
In the title compound, C11H18N22+·2Br, whose cation represents the product of racemization of an L-proline derivative under basic conditions, the pyrrolidinium ring has a distorted envelope conformation with the N atom deviating by 0.533 (6) Å from the mean plane of the remaining four atoms of the ring. The methyl­ene C atom which connects the pyrrolidinium ring and the 2-methyl­pyridine group is displaced from the plane of the four pyrrolidinium C atoms by 0.625 (8) Å in the same direction as the N atom. The cation and anions are linked by N—H...Br hydrogen bonds.

Supporting information

cif

Crystallographic Information File (CIF) https://doi.org/10.1107/S1600536807048003/ya2056sup1.cif
Contains datablocks global, I

hkl

Structure factor file (CIF format) https://doi.org/10.1107/S1600536807048003/ya2056Isup2.hkl
Contains datablock I

CCDC reference: 669136

Key indicators

  • Single-crystal X-ray study
  • T = 298 K
  • Mean [sigma](C-C) = 0.008 Å
  • R factor = 0.045
  • wR factor = 0.139
  • Data-to-parameter ratio = 23.2

checkCIF/PLATON results

No syntax errors found



Alert level B PLAT230_ALERT_2_B Hirshfeld Test Diff for C8 - C9 .. 8.11 su PLAT230_ALERT_2_B Hirshfeld Test Diff for C10 - C11 .. 13.23 su PLAT242_ALERT_2_B Check Low Ueq as Compared to Neighbors for C10
Alert level C PLAT042_ALERT_1_C Calc. and Rep. MoietyFormula Strings Differ .... ? PLAT241_ALERT_2_C Check High Ueq as Compared to Neighbors for C2 PLAT241_ALERT_2_C Check High Ueq as Compared to Neighbors for C7 PLAT241_ALERT_2_C Check High Ueq as Compared to Neighbors for C9 PLAT341_ALERT_3_C Low Bond Precision on C-C Bonds (x 1000) Ang ... 8
Alert level G PLAT793_ALERT_1_G Check the Absolute Configuration of C4 = ... S
0 ALERT level A = In general: serious problem 3 ALERT level B = Potentially serious problem 5 ALERT level C = Check and explain 1 ALERT level G = General alerts; check 2 ALERT type 1 CIF construction/syntax error, inconsistent or missing data 6 ALERT type 2 Indicator that the structure model may be wrong or deficient 1 ALERT type 3 Indicator that the structure quality may be low 0 ALERT type 4 Improvement, methodology, query or suggestion 0 ALERT type 5 Informative message, check

Comment top

There has been growing interest (Ishii et al., 2004; Andrey et al., 2004) in the studies of catalytic properties of proline and its derivatives. The title compound (I), a quaternary ammonium salt obtained from L-proline, can act as organocatalyst in several important processes such as the Michael reaction, the Mannich reaction and others. When this compound was used as a catalyst of the Michael addition of cyclohexanone to nitroolefins, the products were obtained in good yields, however the reactions showed poor enantioselectivities. In order to establish the structure of (I) unambiguously, as well as to investigate the reason for the above mentioned lack of enantioselectivity, the X-ray analysis of (I) was undertaken. The structure of (I) is shown in Fig. 1.

It came as a surprise, that the crystal of (I) turned out to be racemic and crystallize in centrosymmetric space group, even though it was prepared from the chiral L-proline derivative. It is known however that in basic conditions under heating L-proline and its derivatives may undergo racemization (Ebbers et al., 1997).

The crystal of (I) is built of pyrrolidinium dications and bromide anions. The N21 atom of the pyrrolidinium ring and the C5 atom are displaced from the mean plane of C1, C2, C3, C4 in the same direction by 0.533 (6) and 0.625 (8) Å. Thanks to two N—H···Br bonds (Table 2) the dications and anions form "ion-pairs" in crystal of (I).

Related literature top

See Ishii et al. (2004) and Andrey et al. (2004) for the catalytic properties of L-proline. The synthesis of (S)-(+)-2-bromomethylpyrrolidine hydrobromide is described by Xu et al. (2006). Details of the racemization of amino acids under basic conditions are given by Ebbers et al. (1997). For the method used for the extinction correction, see: Larson (1970).

Experimental top

The title compound was synthesized by treating of 2-methylpyridine (1.10 g, 11 mmol) with (S)-(+)-2-bromomethylpyrrolidine hydrobromide (2.50 g, 10 mmol; see Xu et al., 2006 for the synthesis of the latter) in MeCN (30 ml) under stirring at 353 K for 24 h (yield 95%). The reaction is accompanied by racemization of the L-proline derivative. Suitable crystals of the title compound were obtained by slow evaporation of ethanol solution at room temperature (m.p. 421 K).

Refinement top

The H211 and H212 atoms were located in a difference Fourier map; all carbon-bound H atoms were placed in calculated position with C—H = 0.98 Å (sp), C—H = 0.97 Å (sp2), C—H = 0.96 Å (sp3), C—H = 0.93 Å (aromatic). All H atoms included in the final cycles of refinement in the riding motion approximation, with Uiso(H) = 1.2Ueq of the carrier atoms.

Structure description top

There has been growing interest (Ishii et al., 2004; Andrey et al., 2004) in the studies of catalytic properties of proline and its derivatives. The title compound (I), a quaternary ammonium salt obtained from L-proline, can act as organocatalyst in several important processes such as the Michael reaction, the Mannich reaction and others. When this compound was used as a catalyst of the Michael addition of cyclohexanone to nitroolefins, the products were obtained in good yields, however the reactions showed poor enantioselectivities. In order to establish the structure of (I) unambiguously, as well as to investigate the reason for the above mentioned lack of enantioselectivity, the X-ray analysis of (I) was undertaken. The structure of (I) is shown in Fig. 1.

It came as a surprise, that the crystal of (I) turned out to be racemic and crystallize in centrosymmetric space group, even though it was prepared from the chiral L-proline derivative. It is known however that in basic conditions under heating L-proline and its derivatives may undergo racemization (Ebbers et al., 1997).

The crystal of (I) is built of pyrrolidinium dications and bromide anions. The N21 atom of the pyrrolidinium ring and the C5 atom are displaced from the mean plane of C1, C2, C3, C4 in the same direction by 0.533 (6) and 0.625 (8) Å. Thanks to two N—H···Br bonds (Table 2) the dications and anions form "ion-pairs" in crystal of (I).

See Ishii et al. (2004) and Andrey et al. (2004) for the catalytic properties of L-proline. The synthesis of (S)-(+)-2-bromomethylpyrrolidine hydrobromide is described by Xu et al. (2006). Details of the racemization of amino acids under basic conditions are given by Ebbers et al. (1997). For the method used for the extinction correction, see: Larson (1970).

Computing details top

Data collection: PROCESS-AUTO (Rigaku, 1998); cell refinement: PROCESS-AUTO (Rigaku, 1998); data reduction: CrystalStructure (Rigaku/MSC & Rigaku, 2004); program(s) used to solve structure: SHELXS97 (Sheldrick, 1997); program(s) used to refine structure: CRYSTALS (Watkin et al., 1996); molecular graphics: ORTEP-3 for Windows (Farrugia, 1997); software used to prepare material for publication: CrystalStructure (Rigaku/MSC & Rigaku, 2004).

Figures top
[Figure 1] Fig. 1. The asymmetric unit of the structure of the title compound, with the atomic labeling scheme. Displacement ellipsoids are drawn at the 40% probability level. Atomic labels are shown only for those H atoms which participate in the H-bonding.
2-Methyl-1-(pyrrolidinium-2-ylmethyl)pyridinium dibromide top
Crystal data top
C11H18N22+·2BrF(000) = 672.00
Mr = 338.08Dx = 1.612 Mg m3
Monoclinic, P21/cMelting point: 148 K
Hall symbol: -P 2ybcMo Kα radiation, λ = 0.71075 Å
a = 12.588 (3) ÅCell parameters from 9608 reflections
b = 10.023 (4) Åθ = 3.1–27.5°
c = 12.461 (4) ŵ = 5.81 mm1
β = 117.617 (13)°T = 298 K
V = 1393.1 (8) Å3Block, yellow
Z = 40.26 × 0.19 × 0.17 mm
Data collection top
Rigaku R-AXIS RAPID
diffractometer
2192 reflections with I > 2σ(I)
Detector resolution: 10.00 pixels mm-1Rint = 0.032
ω scansθmax = 27.5°
Absorption correction: multi-scan
(ABSCOR; Higashi, 1995)
h = 1616
Tmin = 0.225, Tmax = 0.372k = 1213
13165 measured reflectionsl = 1416
3178 independent reflections
Refinement top
Refinement on F2H-atom parameters constrained
R[F2 > 2σ(F2)] = 0.045 w = 1/[0.0017Fo2 + 1.0σ(Fo2)]/(4Fo2)
wR(F2) = 0.139(Δ/σ)max < 0.001
S = 1.01Δρmax = 0.88 e Å3
3178 reflectionsΔρmin = 0.69 e Å3
137 parametersExtinction correction: Larson (1970)
0 restraintsExtinction coefficient: 28 (2)
Crystal data top
C11H18N22+·2BrV = 1393.1 (8) Å3
Mr = 338.08Z = 4
Monoclinic, P21/cMo Kα radiation
a = 12.588 (3) ŵ = 5.81 mm1
b = 10.023 (4) ÅT = 298 K
c = 12.461 (4) Å0.26 × 0.19 × 0.17 mm
β = 117.617 (13)°
Data collection top
Rigaku R-AXIS RAPID
diffractometer
3178 independent reflections
Absorption correction: multi-scan
(ABSCOR; Higashi, 1995)
2192 reflections with I > 2σ(I)
Tmin = 0.225, Tmax = 0.372Rint = 0.032
13165 measured reflections
Refinement top
R[F2 > 2σ(F2)] = 0.0450 restraints
wR(F2) = 0.139H-atom parameters constrained
S = 1.01Δρmax = 0.88 e Å3
3178 reflectionsΔρmin = 0.69 e Å3
137 parameters
Special details top

Refinement. Refinement using all reflections. The weighted R-factor (wR) and goodness of fit (S) are based on F2. R-factor (gt) are based on F. The threshold expression of F2 > 2.0 σ(F2) is used only for calculating R-factor (gt).

Fractional atomic coordinates and isotropic or equivalent isotropic displacement parameters (Å2) top
xyzUiso*/Ueq
Br10.41438 (4)0.56892 (5)0.64583 (4)0.06054 (16)
Br20.08574 (4)0.16025 (5)0.45070 (4)0.05775 (16)
N210.3228 (3)0.3124 (3)0.4761 (2)0.0487 (9)
N220.1717 (2)0.5515 (3)0.3133 (2)0.0516 (10)
C10.4223 (4)0.2119 (6)0.5167 (5)0.0741 (17)
C20.4018 (6)0.1369 (6)0.4052 (5)0.094 (2)
C30.3048 (5)0.2097 (5)0.2990 (4)0.0762 (18)
C40.2946 (3)0.3451 (4)0.3492 (3)0.0481 (12)
C50.1739 (4)0.4108 (4)0.2777 (3)0.0511 (12)
C60.1146 (4)0.5837 (6)0.3801 (4)0.087 (2)
C70.1090 (7)0.7146 (7)0.4121 (7)0.119 (3)
C80.1624 (7)0.8095 (9)0.3721 (7)0.106 (3)
C90.2193 (5)0.7798 (4)0.3032 (5)0.106 (2)
C100.2226 (3)0.6472 (3)0.2744 (4)0.0577 (13)
C110.2778 (6)0.6100 (7)0.1949 (6)0.119 (2)
H40.35700.40430.35020.058*
H60.07920.51680.40440.104*
H70.07120.73780.45820.142*
H80.15980.89820.39270.127*
H90.25390.84610.27730.128*
H1010.41900.15200.57630.089*
H1020.49950.25630.55140.089*
H1110.34840.55760.24040.143*
H1120.22130.55920.12710.143*
H1130.29890.68960.16630.143*
H2010.37640.04640.40900.112*
H2020.47500.13450.39740.112*
H2110.34890.38710.52890.057*
H2120.26040.27400.47960.057*
H3010.32710.22050.23470.091*
H3020.22950.16170.26830.091*
H5010.15340.40840.19250.061*
H5020.11460.36100.29050.061*
Atomic displacement parameters (Å2) top
U11U22U33U12U13U23
Br10.0632 (3)0.0577 (3)0.0598 (3)0.0061 (2)0.0278 (2)0.0152 (2)
Br20.0576 (3)0.0641 (3)0.0493 (3)0.0091 (2)0.0228 (2)0.0049 (2)
N210.0508 (19)0.050 (2)0.0420 (18)0.0043 (16)0.0184 (15)0.0055 (15)
N220.0438 (18)0.064 (2)0.0402 (18)0.0065 (17)0.0138 (14)0.0026 (17)
C10.071 (3)0.074 (3)0.068 (3)0.024 (2)0.024 (2)0.005 (2)
C20.125 (5)0.070 (4)0.074 (3)0.039 (3)0.036 (3)0.005 (3)
C30.112 (4)0.060 (3)0.062 (3)0.015 (3)0.045 (3)0.008 (2)
C40.057 (2)0.043 (2)0.048 (2)0.0016 (19)0.0284 (19)0.0019 (18)
C50.056 (2)0.050 (2)0.041 (2)0.012 (2)0.0174 (18)0.0013 (19)
C60.053 (2)0.147 (6)0.051 (2)0.025 (3)0.017 (2)0.004 (3)
C70.087 (5)0.153 (12)0.079 (5)0.023 (6)0.008 (4)0.019 (7)
C80.081 (7)0.110 (8)0.075 (6)0.067 (6)0.007 (4)0.012 (5)
C90.087 (4)0.058 (3)0.107 (5)0.011 (3)0.012 (4)0.007 (3)
C100.051 (2)0.044 (2)0.061 (2)0.002 (2)0.011 (2)0.006 (2)
C110.148 (6)0.089 (5)0.110 (5)0.021 (5)0.052 (5)0.030 (4)
Geometric parameters (Å, º) top
N21—C11.500 (6)C1—H1010.970
N21—C41.488 (6)C1—H1020.970
N22—C51.483 (5)C2—H2010.970
N22—C61.367 (7)C2—H2020.970
N22—C101.361 (6)C3—H3010.970
C1—C21.494 (9)C3—H3020.970
C2—C31.509 (7)C4—H40.980
C3—C41.524 (7)C5—H5010.970
C4—C51.511 (5)C5—H5020.970
C6—C71.383 (10)C6—H60.930
C7—C81.384 (13)C7—H70.930
C8—C91.382 (13)C8—H80.930
C9—C101.382 (6)C9—H90.930
C10—C111.496 (11)C11—H1110.960
N21—H2110.949C11—H1120.960
N21—H2120.895C11—H1130.960
Br1···N213.186 (3)H101···H201ix3.192
Br2···N213.234 (4)H101···H202ix3.119
Br2···N22i3.554 (2)H101···H301vi2.998
Br2···C10i3.586 (3)H102···Br1iii3.571
N21···Br13.186 (3)H102···C9iii3.161
N21···Br23.234 (4)H102···C10iii3.293
N22···Br2ii3.554 (2)H102···C11iii3.381
C10···Br2ii3.586 (3)H102···H9iii3.017
Br1···H4iii2.868H102···H111iii3.045
Br1···H9iv3.250H102···H113iii3.292
Br1···H101v3.217H102···H201ix3.343
Br1···H102iii3.571H111···Br1iii2.934
Br1···H111iii2.934H111···H101xiii3.326
Br1···H113iv2.895H111···H102iii3.045
Br1···H202iii3.429H111···H202xiv3.467
Br1···H202vi3.514H111···H211iii3.596
Br1···H2112.239H112···Br2xiii3.018
Br1···H301iii3.574H112···C7xi3.288
Br1···H301vi3.461H112···C8xi3.193
Br2···H7vii2.883H112···H7xi2.908
Br2···H8viii2.986H112···H8xi2.686
Br2···H112vi3.018H112···H101xiii3.540
Br2···H2122.351H113···Br1xi2.895
Br2···H3023.501H113···C7xi3.106
Br2···H501vi2.810H113···C8xi3.248
Br2···H5022.973H113···H7xi2.929
N21···H301vi3.215H113···H8xi3.150
C1···H201ix3.437H113···H102iii3.292
C1···H301vi3.505H113···H202xiv3.336
C2···H9viii3.428H201···C1ix3.437
C2···H201ix3.246H201···C2ix3.246
C2···H202ix3.510H201···C8viii3.458
C5···H7i3.572H201···C9viii3.221
C7···H112iv3.288H201···H8viii3.027
C7···H113iv3.106H201···H9viii2.600
C7···H501ii3.520H201···H101ix3.192
C7···H502ii3.141H201···H102ix3.343
C8···H112iv3.193H201···H201ix3.026
C8···H113iv3.248H201···H202ix2.903
C8···H201x3.458H202···Br1iii3.429
C8···H502ii3.160H202···Br1xiii3.514
C9···H102iii3.161H202···C2ix3.510
C9···H201x3.221H202···H101ix3.119
C10···H102iii3.293H202···H111xv3.467
C11···H7xi3.268H202···H113xv3.336
C11···H8xi3.348H202···H201ix2.903
C11···H102iii3.381H202···H202ix3.566
H4···Br1iii2.868H211···Br12.239
H7···Br2vii2.883H211···H111iii3.596
H7···C5ii3.572H211···H301vi2.910
H7···C11iv3.268H212···Br22.351
H7···H112iv2.908H212···H301vi2.888
H7···H113iv2.929H301···Br1iii3.574
H7···H501ii3.086H301···Br1xiii3.461
H7···H502ii3.144H301···N21xiii3.215
H8···Br2x2.986H301···C1xiii3.505
H8···C11iv3.348H301···H101xiii2.998
H8···H112iv2.686H301···H211xiii2.910
H8···H113iv3.150H301···H212xiii2.888
H8···H201x3.027H302···Br23.501
H8···H302x3.378H302···H8viii3.378
H8···H501ii3.578H302···H9viii3.175
H8···H502ii3.159H501···Br2xiii2.810
H9···Br1xi3.250H501···C7i3.520
H9···C2x3.428H501···H7i3.086
H9···H102iii3.017H501···H8i3.578
H9···H201x2.600H502···Br22.973
H9···H302x3.175H502···C7i3.141
H101···Br1xii3.217H502···C8i3.160
H101···H111vi3.326H502···H7i3.144
H101···H112vi3.540H502···H8i3.159
C1—N21—C4104.9 (4)C3—C2—H201110.1
C5—N22—C6119.6 (4)C3—C2—H202110.1
C5—N22—C10119.1 (4)H201—C2—H202109.5
C6—N22—C10121.2 (4)C2—C3—H301110.6
N21—C1—C2105.5 (4)C2—C3—H302110.6
C1—C2—C3107.0 (5)C4—C3—H301110.6
C2—C3—C4105.0 (4)C4—C3—H302110.6
N21—C4—C3102.5 (3)H301—C3—H302109.5
N21—C4—C5113.7 (4)N21—C4—H4109.0
C3—C4—C5113.5 (3)C3—C4—H4109.0
N22—C5—C4113.0 (3)C5—C4—H4109.0
N22—C6—C7120.7 (6)N22—C5—H501108.6
C6—C7—C8116.8 (9)N22—C5—H502108.6
C7—C8—C9123.6 (8)C4—C5—H501108.6
C8—C9—C10117.1 (6)C4—C5—H502108.6
N22—C10—C9120.6 (5)H501—C5—H502109.5
N22—C10—C11120.0 (4)N22—C6—H6119.7
C9—C10—C11119.3 (5)C7—C6—H6119.7
C1—N21—H211109.2C6—C7—H7121.6
C1—N21—H212108.0C8—C7—H7121.6
C4—N21—H211113.5C7—C8—H8118.2
C4—N21—H212111.3C9—C8—H8118.2
H211—N21—H212109.6C8—C9—H9121.5
N21—C1—H101110.5C10—C9—H9121.5
N21—C1—H102110.5C10—C11—H111109.5
C2—C1—H101110.5C10—C11—H112109.5
C2—C1—H102110.5C10—C11—H113109.5
H101—C1—H102109.5H111—C11—H112109.5
C1—C2—H201110.1H111—C11—H113109.5
C1—C2—H202110.1H112—C11—H113109.5
C1—N21—C4—C339.2 (4)N21—C1—C2—C39.6 (7)
C1—N21—C4—C5162.2 (3)C1—C2—C3—C414.4 (7)
C4—N21—C1—C230.8 (5)C2—C3—C4—N2132.9 (6)
C5—N22—C6—C7178.5 (4)C2—C3—C4—C5155.9 (5)
C6—N22—C5—C4106.0 (4)N21—C4—C5—N2273.6 (5)
C5—N22—C10—C9178.2 (3)C3—C4—C5—N22169.7 (4)
C5—N22—C10—C111.1 (5)N22—C6—C7—C80.7 (7)
C10—N22—C5—C476.7 (4)C6—C7—C8—C90.2 (7)
C6—N22—C10—C91.0 (5)C7—C8—C9—C100.4 (9)
C6—N22—C10—C11176.2 (3)C8—C9—C10—N220.1 (5)
C10—N22—C6—C71.3 (6)C8—C9—C10—C11177.0 (5)
Symmetry codes: (i) x, y1/2, z+1/2; (ii) x, y+1/2, z+1/2; (iii) x+1, y+1, z+1; (iv) x, y+3/2, z+1/2; (v) x+1, y+1/2, z+3/2; (vi) x, y+1/2, z+1/2; (vii) x, y+1, z+1; (viii) x, y1, z; (ix) x+1, y, z+1; (x) x, y+1, z; (xi) x, y+3/2, z1/2; (xii) x+1, y1/2, z+3/2; (xiii) x, y+1/2, z1/2; (xiv) x+1, y+1/2, z+1/2; (xv) x+1, y1/2, z+1/2.
Hydrogen-bond geometry (Å, º) top
D—H···AD—HH···AD···AD—H···A
N21—H211···Br10.952.243.186 (3)176
N21—H212···Br20.902.353.233 (3)169

Experimental details

Crystal data
Chemical formulaC11H18N22+·2Br
Mr338.08
Crystal system, space groupMonoclinic, P21/c
Temperature (K)298
a, b, c (Å)12.588 (3), 10.023 (4), 12.461 (4)
β (°) 117.617 (13)
V3)1393.1 (8)
Z4
Radiation typeMo Kα
µ (mm1)5.81
Crystal size (mm)0.26 × 0.19 × 0.17
Data collection
DiffractometerRigaku R-AXIS RAPID
Absorption correctionMulti-scan
(ABSCOR; Higashi, 1995)
Tmin, Tmax0.225, 0.372
No. of measured, independent and
observed [I > 2σ(I)] reflections
13165, 3178, 2192
Rint0.032
(sin θ/λ)max1)0.650
Refinement
R[F2 > 2σ(F2)], wR(F2), S 0.045, 0.139, 1.01
No. of reflections3178
No. of parameters137
H-atom treatmentH-atom parameters constrained
Δρmax, Δρmin (e Å3)0.88, 0.69

Computer programs: PROCESS-AUTO (Rigaku, 1998), CrystalStructure (Rigaku/MSC & Rigaku, 2004), SHELXS97 (Sheldrick, 1997), CRYSTALS (Watkin et al., 1996), ORTEP-3 for Windows (Farrugia, 1997).

Hydrogen-bond geometry (Å, º) top
D—H···AD—HH···AD···AD—H···A
N21—H211···Br10.9492.2383.186 (3)176
N21—H212···Br20.8952.3513.233 (3)169
 

Subscribe to Acta Crystallographica Section E: Crystallographic Communications

The full text of this article is available to subscribers to the journal.

If you have already registered and are using a computer listed in your registration details, please email support@iucr.org for assistance.

Buy online

You may purchase this article in PDF and/or HTML formats. For purchasers in the European Community who do not have a VAT number, VAT will be added at the local rate. Payments to the IUCr are handled by WorldPay, who will accept payment by credit card in several currencies. To purchase the article, please complete the form below (fields marked * are required), and then click on `Continue'.
E-mail address* 
Repeat e-mail address* 
(for error checking) 

Format*   PDF (US $40)
   HTML (US $40)
   PDF+HTML (US $50)
In order for VAT to be shown for your country javascript needs to be enabled.

VAT number 
(non-UK EC countries only) 
Country* 
 

Terms and conditions of use
Contact us

Follow Acta Cryst. E
Sign up for e-alerts
Follow Acta Cryst. on Twitter
Follow us on facebook
Sign up for RSS feeds