Solution of the structure of the cofactor-binding fragment of CysB: a struggle against non-isomorphism

The elucidation of the structure of CysB(88-324) by multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) techniques was seriously delayed by problems encountered at every stage of the analysis. There was extensive non-isomorphism both between different native crystals and between native and heavy-atom-soaked crystals. The heavy-atom substitution was invariably weak and different soaking experiments frequently led to substitution at common sites. These correlated heavy-atom binding sites resulted in an overestimation of the phase information. Missing low-resolution reflections in the native data set, constituting only 2% of the total observations, reduced the power of density modification and phase re­finement. Finally, the extensive dimer interface made it difficult to isolate a single molecule in the course of model building into the MIR maps. The power of maximum-likeli­hood refinement (REFMAC) was exploited in solving the structure by means of iterative cycles of refinement of a partial model, initially comprising only 30% of the protein atoms in the final coordinate set. This technique, which uses experimental phases, can automatically discriminate the correct and incorrect parts of electron-density maps and give properly weighted combined phases which are better than the experimental or calculated ones. This allowed the model to be gradually extended by manual building into improved electron-density maps. A model generated in this way, con­taining just 50% of the protein atoms, proved good enough to find the transformations needed for multi-crystal averaging between different crystal forms. The averaging regime im­proved the phasing dramatically such that the complete model could be built. The problems, final solutions and some possible causes for the observed lack of isomorphism are discussed.